Crimson and Clover

As part of work to do provide coverage reports for the TCK of JCache we had to add a coverage tool. As we are open source I spent some time playing with coverage tools.

We build with Maven 3. For reasons do with usage of the TCK, we have four standalone modules: jsr107soec, jsr107tck, RI and Demo. Within the jsr107tck and RI there is a parent pom and children with back references to their parents. To easily run the four top level modules we have an aggregate module which is not declared as a parent in the poms of the four top level modules. It looks like this.

An unusual aspect of this arrangements is that all tests for the RI are contained in the jsr107tck module. The RI itself has no tests.

My approach was to spend a few hours with first the open source coverage tools, Emma and Cobertura, and then to move on to Clover which I have used before, if needed.

Emma’s Maven plugin is old and needs a work around for Java 7. But got it basically working but could not get it to deal with our complicated structure.

Then I tried Cobertura. Version 2.6 of the Maven module was released just in August. It worked fine with Java 7. But once again I found it difficult to make progress with our complicated structure. I was thinking the best approach would be to give all modules the same coverage database location. In Cobertura you do this with a system property. e.g. -Dnet.sourceforge.cobertura.datafile=/path/cobertura.ser . I didn’t get this working.

I then tried Clover, and got up and running. I specified the same clover.db location for all modules. I needed to add this to the aggregate pom, and each top level pom. For those top level modules with children, defining it in the parent was sufficient. I added the following to each of those poms.

Then to run a build with clover instrumentation:
mvn clean com.atlassian.maven.plugins:maven-clover2-plugin:setup install

And to run the clover report:
mvn com.atlassian.maven.plugins:maven-clover2-plugin:clover

Note the wordy module definitions. You can use the short name of clover2 if you add the following to your settings.xml:


The first example then becomes:
mvn clean clover2:setup install

It would be great if they could change the User Guide to point out this step as it mars what is otherwise a very smooth experience.